Blessing Omale, Abuja
The Federal High Court in Abuja has declared former Benue State Governor, Gabriel Suswam, the duly nominated candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) for the 2027 Benue North East Senatorial District election, nullifying the emergence of incumbent Senator Emmanuel Udende as the party’s candidate.
Justice Inyang Ekwo, in a judgment delivered on Wednesday, held that Suswam successfully established his claim through documentary evidence showing that he won the APC senatorial primary election conducted on May 18.
The court found that Suswam secured 131,083 votes against Udende’s 1,364 votes, relying on the primary election result and the report of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), which monitored the exercise.
Justice Ekwo held that the APC acted in violation of the Electoral Act, the 1999 Constitution, as amended, and its own constitution when it substituted Suswam’s name with that of Udende despite evidence that the former governor had won the primary.
The judge noted that neither the APC nor Udende presented any evidence to contradict the result of the primary or INEC’s report identifying Suswam as the winner.
Consequently, the court ordered the APC to transmit Suswam’s name to INEC as its candidate for the Benue North East Senatorial District election.
It also directed INEC to publish Suswam’s name as the party’s candidate for the 2027 general elections.
The judgment followed a suit filed by Suswam, marked FHC/ABJ/CS/1470/2026, challenging the APC’s decision to replace his name with that of Udende after the May 18 primary.
Suswam had approached the court seeking recognition as the party’s candidate, arguing that he emerged victorious in the primary but was subsequently substituted by the party.
Before determining the substantive issues, Justice Ekwo dismissed the preliminary objections raised by the APC and Udende, rejecting their arguments that the dispute concerned the internal affairs of the political party and was therefore not subject to judicial intervention.
The judge held that the dispute was not exclusively an internal party matter, explaining that the court could assume jurisdiction where an aspirant who participated in a political party’s primary election alleged violations of the Electoral Act, the party’s constitution or its electoral guidelines.
He maintained that compliance with the Electoral Act remained mandatory for political parties and that the provisions of the law took precedence over a party’s internal guidelines.
According to the judge, the argument that a dispute arose from the internal affairs of a political party could not automatically prevent the court from examining allegations of non-compliance with statutory provisions.
Ekwo also rejected the defendants’ argument that the suit was statute-barred, holding that Suswam had the legal standing to institute the action because he participated in the primary election and was directly affected by the party’s decision.
On the substantive issues, the court found that the evidence presented by Suswam, particularly INEC’s report and the primary election result, established that he won the exercise.
The judge observed that the APC and Udende failed to produce any contrary result or documentary evidence capable of discrediting the figures recorded by the electoral commission.
He also faulted the APC’s decision to substitute Suswam’s name based on the report of its appeal committee.
Justice Ekwo noted that the appeal committee’s report was dated May 18, the same day the primary election was conducted, and held that there was no evidence establishing that Suswam was given an opportunity to be heard before the decision to replace him was taken.
The judge consequently held that the party’s action violated Suswam’s right to fair hearing.
During the proceedings, Anthony Malik, SAN, counsel to INEC, told the court that the commission’s documents before it showed that Suswam won the APC primary election.
Malik urged the court to rely on the commission’s report and the result of the exercise in determining the dispute.
Similarly, Jibrin Okutepa, SAN, counsel to Suswam, urged the court to grant the reliefs sought by his client, arguing that the preliminary objections raised by the APC and Udende were without merit.
However, A. G. Yirvoms, counsel to the APC, urged the court to uphold the party’s preliminary objection and dismiss the suit.
In resolving the substantive issues in Suswam’s favour, Justice Ekwo granted the reliefs sought, affirming the former governor’s emergence as the APC candidate for the 2027 Benue North East Senatorial District election.
For a better society
_______________________________
Follow us across our platforms:
Instagram – https://www.instagram.com/championnewsonline/
Facebook – https://web.facebook.com/championnewsonline
LinkedIn – https://www.linkedin.com/company/champion-newspapers-limited/
https://x.com/championnewsng/
You can also like and comment on our YouTube videos.
https://youtu.be/QIBfD1tT80w?si=R4Qf3so2LxYu3GC2